Jump to content

Triumph TR4A overheating


Recommended Posts

10 hours ago, Andy Moltu said:

Refill the water in the morning.

Start it up, keep an eye on the temperature gauge and check the top hose to confirm the thermostat is opening properly. If not you probably have solved the problem

Do you still have the mechanical fan or just the electric fan?  If just the electrical one, check it switches on as the temperature rises, or manually switch it on and see if keeps the temperature down.

I had Scimitar GTE 5A that seemed to gobble up thermostats with alarming regularity.

Hi Andy

Fan is electrical with switch under the dash worked fine yesterday if it turns out its the thermostat Revingtons are 25 minutes from home so can pop out to get a replacement

Link to post
Share on other sites

Good Morning  

Before I started the car I check water level on the radiator levels spot on car started no problem on choke ran the car for 20 minutes and the gauge did not move above the halfway mark didn't bother with the fan until the three quarter mark reached once back to halfway switched engine off

Noted the following 

Small amout of steam leakage around the radiator cap (which is about a year old) 7lbs pressure on the cap

Top hose radiator to thermostat housing remained hot as you would expect

Bottom hose hot

Bypass hose hot

Radiator top and bottom hot to what one would expect

Going to order a new pressure cap and see what happens couldn't get out for a real world drive as we have the tree surgeons here

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Tiger123 said:

Good Morning  

Before I started the car I check water level on the radiator levels spot on car started no problem on choke ran the car for 20 minutes and the gauge did not move above the halfway mark didn't bother with the fan until the three quarter mark reached once back to halfway switched engine off

Noted the following 

Small amout of steam leakage around the radiator cap (which is about a year old) 7lbs pressure on the cap

Top hose radiator to thermostat housing remained hot as you would expect

Bottom hose hot

Bypass hose hot

Radiator top and bottom hot to what one would expect

Going to order a new pressure cap and see what happens couldn't get out for a real world drive as we have the tree surgeons here

 

 

I think if it’s Spot On now you had to much Water in the Rad before,it’s now found the level of where it should be so hopefully you’ll be good to go.

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, RogerH said:

Hi Terry,

 the steam at the rad cap could easily be water residue evaporating with the hot rad.

 

Roger 

Yes it could be Roger think I need to get the car out on a run and see what happens hopefully this week sometime

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, TR NIALL said:

I think if it’s Spot On now you had to much Water in the Rad before,it’s now found the level of where it should be so hopefully you’ll be good to go.

Yes let's hope so a run out later this week hopefully in a real world traffic will help to confirm if the problem is solved

Link to post
Share on other sites

Good luck with the real world test

If I have understood this correctly, the original mechanical cooling fan has been removed and replaced with an electric fan. However, the electric fan is only operated by a manual switch. Notwithstanding the car's good behaviour in hot conditions, life might be a bit easier for you if the electric fan was connected to a thermo switch in the cooling system so that the fan comes on automatically when the engine starts to get too. A common arrangement is to use an otter switch in a metal downpipe from the radiator, available from the usual suspects. You should also retain the manual switch as an override to switch the fan on when you anticipate things getting really hot. This way you can relax a bit and will not be constantly looking at the temp gauge in hot weather.

Miles

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi guys and gals . 
I just joined the forum and the Register . 
I’m piggybacking onto this post as I also have an overheating issue . I’m going through the usual process and started by checking the coolant level and have now removed the wax thermostat which I shall replace regardless . In my research I have discovered the bellows style thermostat which is considerably more expensive,  are they worth the extra money , what type was fitted originally. I’m aware that my rad cap must not exceed 7psi . 
Any thoughts , observations, suggestions would be appreciated. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

The bellows thermostat isn’t necessarily better or more reliable.

Some of the earlier 4 cylinder engines had no restriction in the flow through the bypass hose. As the engine warms and the stat opens the thermostat closes off flow through the bipass so that the flow goes through the radiator.

Later cars have a restriction in the housing to limit the flow through the bipass hose so there is no need for the thermostat to obscure this opening when the stat is open. If you restrict the bipass on an earlier car you can use a later stat.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, Mick-the-click said:

 are they worth the extra money

In a word- no unless you are concerned about absolute originality. 

The 4-pot engines have a bypass hose which allows water to circulate before the thermostat has opened, while the engine is warming up .  They used a special bellows thermostat with a sleeve on it, and when the thermostat opens, the sleeve closes off the outlet hose to the bypass.  This arrangement has been found to be unnecessary if the bypass pipe has a simple restrictor fitted reducing the diameter to about 6mm, and this allows an ordinary thermostat to be used.  I believe later cars had the housing redesigned with a smaller outlet orifice as standard and your car may have this or it may have a restrictor fitted by a previous owner.  

Ordinary bellows thermostats do not have the sleeve which is why the special ones are so expensive

 

 

Edited by RobH
Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Mick,

the bellows thermostat first is a horrible plug, I wonder how the engines are cooled anyway - but they do!

Second the sleeve is only „a hope“, it can’t close the bypass.

So even fully opened (and the bypass "closed") massiv coolant flows the bypass.

There is a „full size“ post about this issue at this forum.

Ciao, Marco 

Edited by Z320
missing word added
Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, MilesA said:

Good luck with the real world test

If I have understood this correctly, the original mechanical cooling fan has been removed and replaced with an electric fan. However, the electric fan is only operated by a manual switch. Notwithstanding the car's good behaviour in hot conditions, life might be a bit easier for you if the electric fan was connected to a thermo switch in the cooling system so that the fan comes on automatically when the engine starts to get too. A common arrangement is to use an otter switch in a metal downpipe from the radiator, available from the usual suspects. You should also retain the manual switch as an override to switch the fan on when you anticipate things getting really hot. This way you can relax a bit and will not be constantly looking at the temp gauge in hot weather.

Miles

Miles

Thank you for your suggestion I have already started to investigate the setup you have suggested

Regards

Terry

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

So took the car for a test drive this afternoon water temperature was fine but now have a leak from the water pump housing

I guess a new water and gasket required any suggestions as to supplier as we know quality varies from some suppliers

Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, Tiger123 said:

So took the car for a test drive this afternoon water temperature was fine but now have a leak from the water pump housing

I guess a new water and gasket required any suggestions as to supplier as we know quality varies from some suppliers

Terry - is your existing pump an original or period repro pump ie Quinton Hazell - if so you can get it reconditioned at EP Services who will rebuild it with sealed bearings and a ceramic seals - it then comes with a lifetime warranty - details are :

https://www.ep-services.co.uk/1_4_contact-us.html

 

E.P. Services
Unit 1 Central Trading Estate, Cable Street
Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, WV2 2RJ
England
Phone: 01902 452914  Out of hours: 07770 747724 - ask for Paul

Alternatively, I do have a few surplus pumps which have already been done by EPS which I am happy to sell. so if of interest, please send me a PM ( Personal Message - click on my avatar and you will see the message option) with your contact details.

Cheers Rich

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Mick-the-click said:

Hi guys and gals . 
I just joined the forum and the Register . 
I’m piggybacking onto this post as I also have an overheating issue . I’m going through the usual process and started by checking the coolant level and have now removed the wax thermostat which I shall replace regardless . In my research I have discovered the bellows style thermostat which is considerably more expensive,  are they worth the extra money , what type was fitted originally. I’m aware that my rad cap must not exceed 7psi . 
Any thoughts , observations, suggestions would be appreciated. 

Mick(?) - another welcome to the forum from me and good choice of car -is it a 4 or 4A? If the latter, and it turns out you need a new rad ( I hope you don't), I have some really nice original Stanpart rads which I've had recored by a long established local specialist - they are a bargain at £275 outright - see this link to my ad in Classifieds :

https://www.tr-register.co.uk/classified/6105/TR4A-Stanpart-Radiators-Reconditioned-For-Sale-Great-Price

I've also got lots of other cooling system parts so if of interest, please send me a PM ( Personal Message - click on my avatar and you will see the message option) with your contact details.

Cheers Rich

Link to post
Share on other sites

The thing that I find most amazing from reading this thread, is that anyone can run a 4 pot TR in summer, in a traffic jam, without a fan, for over an hour without it over heating. Mine would have melted after 15 minutes.

I can leave mine ticking over on the drive without overheating, but the electric fan cuts in for about 15 seconds approximately once every minute.

Ralph

Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Ralph Whitaker said:

The thing that I find most amazing from reading this thread, is that anyone can run a 4 pot TR in summer, in a traffic jam, without a fan, for over an hour without it over heating. Mine would have melted after 15 minutes.

I can leave mine ticking over on the drive without overheating, but the electric fan cuts in for about 15 seconds approximately once every minute.

Ralph

+2

Midsummer on the M25 coming back from my brothers ( a 25 mile motorway drive to that point) I almost always get stuck in the traffic where it crosses the M4.   That is commonly an half hour first gear crawl.   The fan cuts in and out continually.  Once driving at 25 mph or more the fan cuts out and stays off.    Slow or stop again and the fan will cut in after a few minutes.    The fan cuts in at just under 3/4 hot on the gauge.   The fan drags the temp down quite quickly.   Usual running temp is on or just below 1/2 hot.   The thermostat is 82 degree Tridon.    This has been more prevalent since removing the oil cooler assy, so probably not a direct result of climate change.

Edited by BlueTR3A-5EKT
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Please familiarise yourself with our Terms and Conditions. By using this site, you agree to the following: Terms of Use.